Seven years with your augmentation and not a single problem. Then one day you notice that one side is firmer than the other. It does not hurt, it is not red, you have not knocked it. You touch it more often than you would like to admit, and within a few months that breast is clearly harder, higher and rounder than the other one.
That has a name, it is the most common complication of a breast augmentation, and it does not mean the surgery was done badly.
The capsule is normal. The contracture is not
Your body does not distinguish between an implant and a splinter: what it does with anything that is not its own and cannot be removed is wall it off. It builds a wrapping of fibrous tissue around it and leaves it there, separated from everything else. That wrapping is the capsule, and one hundred per cent of women with implants have one. It is not a complication: it is how the body works, and normally it is thin, soft and unnoticeable.
The problem appears when that capsule, instead of staying a loose sleeve, thickens and contracts. As it shrinks it squeezes the implant, and a squeezed implant deforms: it becomes more spherical, rides upwards and turns rigid to the touch. The breast does not change because the implant has failed — it is usually intact — but because what surrounds it is now shaping it.
Which clears up a common confusion: a breast with contracture feels hard, but the hard part is not the silicone. It is your own tissue.
The four grades
It is classified by what can be seen and what can be felt, and the scale used for decades has four steps:
- Grade I. The breast is soft and looks natural. The capsule is there, but it does not make itself known. This is normal and is not treated.
- Grade II. It feels somewhat firmer, but the appearance is still normal. Nobody would see it from the outside.
- Grade III. As well as firm, it shows: the breast is rounder, higher, with the implant outlined. This is where most women come in.
- Grade IV. All of the above plus pain. The breast is hard, distorted and uncomfortable, sometimes constantly.
The first two grades are not operated on. The last two are the ones that raise the question of surgery, and the fourth is the most urgent, because pain does not settle on its own.
What makes it likelier
There is no single cause, and that is the honest part of the answer. What is known is which things push it along, and almost all of them point the same way: anything that inflames the pocket where the implant lives.
- Minimal contamination at the moment the implant goes in, far below what would count as a visible infection. It is the explanation with most weight today, and the reason for much of what is done in theatre to avoid it.
- A haematoma or a seroma that did not resolve cleanly. Blood or fluid around the implant leaves a thicker capsule.
- The plane. Under the muscle, contracture appears less often than over it; the movement of the pectoral works in your favour.
- Radiotherapy to that breast, before or after the implant went in. It is the single heaviest factor.
- An old rupture of a silicone implant, which keeps the area irritated for years.
- Time. The longer it has been in, the more chances it has had to appear. Which is why this is not a complication of the recovery period: it is a complication of the implant's whole life.
And what does not prevent it, whatever you are told
This needs saying plainly, because a lot of advice circulates that holds up to nothing. Massaging the breast does not prevent a contracture. It was recommended for years; today it is not advised for textured-surface implants and in general there is no evidence that it changes the outcome. Neither do vitamins, creams, supplements, or sleeping in a particular position.
What does reduce the risk are things that happen in theatre and in the first days, not in your routine: how the implant is handled, care taken with the pocket, the plane chosen, and bleeding resolved in time. If someone sells you a home routine that prevents it, they are selling you something that does not exist.
What is done once it has happened
The first step is to look at it, because a breast that hardens is not always a contracture. An ultrasound, and depending on the case an MRI, show whether there is fluid, whether the implant has ruptured, or whether there is something else to explain. That changes the whole conversation.
If it is a contracture and it is grade III or IV, the treatment is surgical, and there are several ways to approach it:
- Remove the capsule. The fibrous tissue doing the squeezing is taken out — whole or in part, depending on what is there — and a new implant is placed. This is the most common route.
- Change the plane. If the implant sat over the muscle, moving it underneath means housing it somewhere that is not the site that contracted. The old pocket is left behind.
- Remove and not replace. This is a legitimate decision and more frequent than it sounds, especially when it is already the second or third time. It is sometimes combined with an adjustment of the skin so the breast keeps a good shape without an implant.
Worth knowing beforehand: a contracture that has been operated on can come back, and the chance of it returning is higher than the chance of it appearing in the first place. Which is why choosing between those three options is not only a technical matter. It also depends on how many times you have been through this already.
An implant is not for life
This is the sentence that is hardest to say in an augmentation consultation, and the one that prevents most of the disappointment. Implants are devices: they have a shell, a filling and wear. They do not expire on a fixed date and they do not have to be changed every ten years as a matter of course, but neither are they an ornament you fit and forget.
Having surgery again does not mean the first operation failed. It means you are carrying a device, and devices get reviewed.
If that is understood on the day the surgery is decided, then on the day a contracture appears the conversation is a different one: not a disaster, but the next step in something you already knew about.
When to come in
When one breast becomes harder than the other, when it changes shape or rides upwards, when you feel the edge of the implant where you did not feel it before, and always if it hurts. Also if one breast changes size from one day to the next, which is something else and also gets looked into.
And even if all is well: a check-up at intervals, with whatever imaging suits your age. Keeping your implant card — make, model and serial number — is part of that.
This article is about a procedure we perform at Sbeltia. The procedure page sets out the timings, the recovery and the risks in writing.
Read about breast augmentation