You arrive with a photo on your phone and a sentence that sums it all up: I want them back where they were. You had two pregnancies, you breastfed, you lost eight kilos, and what you have now is not exactly less breast: it is the same breast somewhere else.

Behind that photo are two different operations that solve two different problems. Confusing them is the most common mix-up in a breast consultation, and an expensive one, because choosing the wrong one shows within three months.

What an implant does

An implant adds volume. It places it behind the gland or behind the muscle, pushes forward, and fills mainly the upper part, which is what empties out with pregnancies and weight loss. That is all it does, and it does it well.

What it does not do is move anything. The nipple stays exactly where it is. If it was low, it stays low, with more breast behind it. And if the skin was already stretched, adding weight does not tighten it: it stretches it a little further. That is the part nobody mentions, and it explains why some women come out of an augmentation feeling worse than before, even when everything went technically well.

There is one case where it does appear to lift, and it is worth naming so you do not expect too much of it: when the breast has little volume but not much excess skin, the implant fills it from the inside and the whole thing looks higher. The nipple did not rise; the hollow that made it look dropped got filled.

What a lift does

A mastopexy — a lift — works on the skin and on the gland, not on the volume. The excess skin is removed, the breast tissue is repositioned higher, and the nipple is raised to where it belongs. The result is the same breast, better placed.

And here is its limit, said without decoration: it does not give you upper fullness. If what you are missing is cleavage, a lift on its own will not provide it; it may even look slightly smaller, because gathering the skin compacts what was there. What it gains is shape, projection and position.

The measurement that decides

It is not a matter of taste, and that tends to be reassuring: there is an anatomical reference looked at in every consultation that organises the conversation. It is where the nipple sits in relation to the inframammary fold, the natural crease beneath the breast.

  • Nipple above the fold. The breast has not dropped. If what you want is volume, an implant answers your question.
  • Nipple level with the fold. This is the borderline. Here it is decided by looking at skin quality, the volume you want, and how much tissue there is.
  • Nipple below the fold. There is real descent. An implant alone usually makes the shape worse here: the breast ends up full on top with the nipple pointing down.
  • Nipple fine, but the gland fallen below it. This is called pseudoptosis, and it is typical after breastfeeding. The answer lies in shape, not in volume.

The distance from the collarbone to the nipple is measured too, along with how much skin there is between the nipple and the fold. These are centimetres, not impressions, which is why the same breast gets the same answer in any serious consultation.

Added to that is something a tape measure cannot capture: the state of the skin. Skin with good elasticity holds an implant for years. Skin with wide stretch marks and little recovery holds it far less, and that weighs on the decision as much as the position of the nipple does.

Both at once

It exists, it is done, and it solves the commonest case of all: a breast that has dropped and is also empty on top. But it is the most demanding of the three operations, and the reason is easy to grasp.

A lift tightens: it removes skin and reduces the envelope. An implant pushes: it adds volume from within. Doing both at once means tightening and filling at the same time, two forces pulling opposite ways. It can be done, it is done well, and even so it is the breast operation that most often needs a touch-up afterwards. That is not a hidden risk: it is information for deciding.

Which is why in some cases it is proposed in two stages: the implant goes in first and the tissues are allowed to settle, and months later the skin is adjusted with the volume already in place. Two operations instead of one, and in exchange each does its own job without fighting the other. Which of the two routes suits you depends on the case, not on the wish to be finished sooner.

The scars, which are part of the decision

An augmentation alone leaves a small scar, hidden in the fold, at the areola or in the armpit. A lift leaves considerably more, because the excess skin has to come out somewhere:

  1. Around the areola. The most discreet, and also the one that lifts least. It suits small amounts of descent.
  2. Around the areola plus a vertical line down to the fold. The most widely used; it allows a real lift and gives shape.
  3. The above plus a horizontal line in the fold. For when there is a lot of skin to remove. The longest, and the most hidden beneath the breast.

None of them disappears. They mature over a good year and end up as pale lines, but they are there. If the idea of a vertical scar is unacceptable to you, that is a real factor in the decision and it belongs on the table on day one, not on the last day.

An implant lifts nothing. It fills what is there, where it is.

What to bring to the consultation

More useful than the photo: the question. "I have no cleavage" is not the same as "I do not like the way they hang", and neither is the same as "in a bra I look fine and out of one I do not". Each of those three sentences points to a different operation, and the one you say is what really organises the conversation.

And two facts that change the timing more than the technique: whether your weight is stable, and whether you have pregnancies ahead. A pregnancy and a period of breastfeeding after a lift can undo much of what was gained, and that is not an argument against operating — there are reasons to do it sooner — but it is a reason to know what you are buying.

When to come in

When the shape bothers you enough to change how you dress. Before that there is nothing to fix, and after it there is no medical hurry either: this is not an operation that has to happen at a particular age.

And sooner if you notice a lump, if one breast changes size or shape on its own, or if a new asymmetry appears. That gets looked into first, and the conversation about shape comes afterwards.

This article is about a procedure we perform at Sbeltia. The procedure page sets out the timings, the recovery and the risks in writing.

Read about breast lift

All articles